Cubone appears in Rock Tunnel in Kanto's post-game in HeartGold and SoulSilver. Thick Club doubles Attack, and Marowak at C-Tier demolishes with boosted Earthquake.
Ability 1Rock HeadAbility 1Protects against recoil damage.Ability 2Lightning RodAbility 2Redirects single-target electric moves to this Pokémon where possible. Absorbs Electric moves, raising Special Attack one stage.
320HP50Attack50Defense95Speed35Sp.Def50Sp.Atk40
Cubone
Marowak
Weak to
Physical
Balanced
35Speed · Very Slow

Is Cubone Good in HeartGold & SoulSilver Playthrough?

Rock Tunnel and Safari Zone encounters. Ground-type with AbilityRock Head preventing recoil. Marowak at level 28 doubles its Attack with Held ItemThick Club, making it one of the hardest physical hitters available. Mostly Kanto postgame timing.

StrongGoodEvenToughBadEEETTSGEGESEEEGEEGGGEFalknerGym 1BugsyGym 2WhitneyGym 3MortyGym 4ChuckGym 5CuboneCatchableMarowakEvolveJasmineGym 6PryceGym 7ClairGym 8BrockGym 9MistyGym 10SurgeGym 11ErikaGym 12JanineGym 13SabrinaGym 14BlaineGym 15BlueGym 16WillE4KogaE4BrunoE4KarenE4LanceChamp*
Falkner
Gym 1
Even

Cubone trades roughly evenly with Falkner's team.

Even
Pidgey
Lv 9
NormalFlying
Keen Eye
TackleSand Attack
Risky
Pidgeotto
Lv 13
NormalFlying
Keen Eye
TackleRoostGust
Bugsy
Gym 2
Even

Cubone trades roughly evenly with Bugsy's team.

Risky
Scyther
Lv 17
BugFlying
Technician
Quick AttackLeerU TurnFocus Energy
You Win
Kakuna
Lv 15
BugPoison
Shed Skin
Poison Sting
Even
Metapod
Lv 15
Bug
Shed Skin
Tackle
Whitney
Gym 3
Even

Cubone trades roughly evenly with Whitney's team.

You Win
Clefairy
Lv 17
Normal
Cute Charm
Double SlapMimicEncoreMetronome
Even
Miltank
Lv 19
Normal
Scrappy
RolloutAttractStompMilk Drink
Morty
Gym 4
Tough

Morty's typing presses Cubone's defenses.

Risky
Gastly
Lv 21
GhostPoison
LevitateImmune to Ground attacks
LickSpiteMean LookCurse
Avoid
Haunter
Lv 21
GhostPoison
LevitateImmune to Ground attacks
HypnosisDream EaterCurseNightmare
Avoid
Gengar
Lv 25
GhostPoison
LevitateImmune to Ground attacks
HypnosisShadow BallMean LookSucker Punch
Risky
Haunter
Lv 23
GhostPoison
LevitateImmune to Ground attacks
CurseMean LookSucker PunchNight Shade
Chuck
Gym 5
Tough

Chuck's team hits Cubone's weaknesses hard.

Risky
Primeape
Lv 29
Fighting
Vital Spirit
LeerDouble TeamFocus PunchRock Slide
Risky
Poliwrath
Lv 31
WaterFighting
Water Absorb
HypnosisSurfFocus PunchBody Slam
Jasmine
Gym 6
Strong

Marowak resists most of Jasmine's coverage and hits back hard.

Easy KO
Magnemite
Lv 30
ElectricSteel
Magnet Pull
ThunderboltSupersonicSonic BoomThunder Wave
Easy KO
Magnemite
Lv 30
ElectricSteel
Sturdy
ThunderboltSupersonicSonic BoomThunder Wave
You Win
Steelix
Lv 35
SteelGround
Sturdy
ScreechSandstormRock ThrowIron Tail
Pryce
Gym 7
Good

Marowak has the type edge here and should clean up Pryce's team.

You Win
Seel
Lv 30
Water
Thick Fat
SnoreHailIcy WindRest
You Win
Dewgong
Lv 32
WaterIce
Thick Fat
Sleep TalkIce ShardAurora BeamRest
You Win
Piloswine
Lv 34
IceGround
Snow Cloak
HailIce FangMud BombBlizzard
Clair
Gym 8
Even

Marowak trades roughly evenly with Clair's team.

Risky
Gyarados
Lv 38
WaterFlying
Intimidate
TwisterDragon RageBiteDragon Pulse
Even
Dragonair
Lv 38
Dragon
Shed Skin
Thunder WaveFire BlastSlamDragon Pulse
Even
Dragonair
Lv 38
Dragon
Shed Skin
Thunder WaveAqua TailSlamDragon Pulse
Risky
Kingdra
Lv 41
WaterDragon
Sniper
SmokescreenHydro PumpHyper BeamDragon Pulse
Brock
Gym 9
Good

Marowak has the type edge here and should clean up Brock's team.

Easy KO
Graveler
Lv 51
RockGround
Sturdy
Defense CurlRock SlideRolloutEarthquake
Easy KO
Rhyhorn
Lv 51
GroundRock
Rock Head
SandstormScary FaceEarthquakeHorn Drill
You Win
Omastar
Lv 53
RockWater
Shell Armor
Ancient PowerBrineProtectSpike Cannon
You Win
Onix
Lv 54
RockGround
Sturdy
Iron TailRock SlideScreechSandstorm
You Win
Kabutops
Lv 52
RockWater
Battle Armor
Rock SlideAqua JetEndureGiga Drain
Misty
Gym 10
Even

Marowak trades roughly evenly with Misty's team.

Even
Golduck
Lv 49
Water
Damp
Water PulseDisablePsych UpPsychic
You Win
Quagsire
Lv 49
WaterGround
Water Absorb
Water PulseAmnesiaEarthquakeRain Dance
You Win
Lapras
Lv 52
WaterIce
Shell Armor
Water PulseSingIce BeamBody Slam
Even
Starmie
Lv 54
WaterPsychic
Natural Cure
Water PulseConfuse RayRecoverIce Beam
Lt. Surge
Gym 11
Strong

Marowak resists most of Lt. Surge's coverage and hits back hard.

Easy KO
Raichu
Lv 51
Electric
Static
Thunder WaveQuick AttackShock WaveDouble Team
Easy KO
Electrode
Lv 47
Electric
Static
Thunder WaveDouble TeamShock WaveLight Screen
Easy KO
Magneton
Lv 47
ElectricSteel
Sturdy
SupersonicDouble TeamShock WaveMirror Shot
Easy KO
Electrode
Lv 47
Electric
Static
ScreechDouble TeamSelf DestructCharge Beam
Easy KO
Electabuzz
Lv 53
Electric
Static
Quick AttackShock WaveLight ScreenLow Kick
Erika
Gym 12
Even

Marowak trades roughly evenly with Erika's team.

Even
Jumpluff
Lv 51
GrassFlying
Chlorophyll
U TurnLeech SeedSunny DayGiga Drain
Even
Tangela
Lv 52
Grass
Chlorophyll
Ancient PowerWring OutGiga DrainSleep Powder
Even
Victreebel
Lv 56
GrassPoison
Chlorophyll
Sunny DaySynthesisGrass KnotLeaf Storm
Risky
Bellossom
Lv 56
Grass
Chlorophyll
Sunny DaySynthesisGiga DrainSolar Beam
Janine
Gym 13
Even

Marowak trades roughly evenly with Janine's team.

Even
Crobat
Lv 47
PoisonFlying
Inner Focus
ScreechSupersonicConfuse RayWing Attack
Risky
Weezing
Lv 44
Poison
LevitateImmune to Ground attacks
Double HitSludge BombToxicExplosion
You Win
Ariados
Lv 47
BugPoison
Insomnia
Scary FacePoison JabPin MissilePsychic
You Win
Ariados
Lv 47
BugPoison
Insomnia
Pin MissilePoison JabSwaggerNight Shade
Even
Venomoth
Lv 50
BugPoison
Tinted Lens
Sludge BombDouble TeamSignal BeamPsychic
Sabrina
Gym 14
Even

Marowak trades roughly evenly with Sabrina's team.

You Win
Espeon
Lv 53
Psychic
Synchronize
Shadow BallSkill SwapCalm MindPsychic
You Win
Mr Mime
Lv 53
Psychic
Filter
MimicLight ScreenSkill SwapPsychic
Even
Alakazam
Lv 55
Psychic
Inner Focus
Skill SwapPsychicEnergy BallReflect
Blaine
Gym 15
Good

Marowak has the type edge here and should clean up Blaine's team.

Easy KO
Magcargo
Lv 54
FireRock
Flame Body
Sunny DaySmogOverheatRock Slide
You Win
Magmar
Lv 54
Fire
Flame Body
Thunder PunchOverheatSunny DayConfuse Ray
You Win
Rapidash
Lv 59
Fire
Flash FireImmune to Fire attacks
Quick AttackFlare BlitzBounceOverheat
Blue
Gym 16
Even

Marowak trades roughly evenly with Blue's team.

Risky
Exeggutor
Lv 55
GrassPsychic
Chlorophyll
Leaf StormPsychicHypnosisTrick Room
You Win
Arcanine
Lv 58
Fire
Intimidate
RoarDragon PulseFlare BlitzExtreme Speed
You Win
Rhydon
Lv 58
GroundRock
Rock Head
MegahornStone EdgeThunder FangEarthquake
Risky
Gyarados
Lv 52
WaterFlying
Intimidate
Ice FangWaterfallDragon DanceReturn
You Win
Machamp
Lv 56
Fighting
No Guard
Dynamic PunchEarthquakeStone EdgeThunder Punch
Risky
Pidgeot
Lv 60
NormalFlying
Tangled Feet
ReturnWhirlwindAir SlashMirror Move
Will
Elite Four
Even

Marowak trades roughly evenly with Will's team.

Even
Xatu
Lv 40
PsychicFlying
Synchronize
U TurnMe FirstConfuse RayPsychic
You Win
Jynx
Lv 41
IcePsychic
Oblivious
Double SlapLovely KissIce PunchPsychic
Even
Exeggutor
Lv 41
GrassPsychic
Chlorophyll
ReflectHypnosisEgg BombPsychic
You Win
Slowbro
Lv 41
WaterPsychic
Own Tempo
CurseAmnesiaWater PulsePsychic
Even
Xatu
Lv 42
PsychicFlying
Early Bird
Aerial AceOminous WindConfuse RayPsychic
Koga
Elite Four
Good

Marowak has the type edge here and should clean up Koga's team.

You Win
Ariados
Lv 40
BugPoison
Insomnia
Poison JabSpider WebBaton PassGiga Drain
You Win
Venomoth
Lv 41
BugPoison
Tinted Lens
SupersonicGustPsychicToxic
Easy KO
Forretress
Lv 43
BugSteel
Sturdy
ProtectSwiftExplosionToxic Spikes
Easy KO
Muk
Lv 42
Poison
Sticky Hold
MinimizeScreechGunk ShotToxic
Even
Crobat
Lv 44
PoisonFlying
Inner Focus
Double TeamQuick AttackWing AttackPoison Fang
Bruno
Elite Four
Good

Marowak has the type edge here and should clean up Bruno's team.

You Win
Hitmontop
Lv 42
Fighting
Technician
CounterQuick AttackDigTriple Kick
You Win
Hitmonlee
Lv 42
Fighting
Reckless
SwaggerFocus EnergyHigh Jump KickBlaze Kick
You Win
Hitmonchan
Lv 42
Fighting
Iron Fist
Thunder PunchIce PunchFire PunchBullet Punch
You Win
Onix
Lv 43
RockGround
Sturdy
Dragon BreathEarthquakeSandstormRock Slide
You Win
Machamp
Lv 46
Fighting
No Guard
Rock SlideForesightRevengeCross Chop
Karen
Elite Four
Good

Marowak has the type edge here and should clean up Karen's team.

You Win
Umbreon
Lv 42
Dark
Synchronize
Double TeamConfuse RayFeint AttackPayback
Even
Vileplume
Lv 42
GrassPoison
Chlorophyll
Stun SporeAcidMoonlightPetal Dance
Even
Gengar
Lv 45
GhostPoison
LevitateImmune to Ground attacks
LickSpiteFocus BlastDestiny Bond
Even
Murkrow
Lv 44
DarkFlying
Super Luck
PluckWhirlwindSucker PunchFeint Attack
Easy KO
Houndoom
Lv 47
DarkFire
Flash FireImmune to Fire attacks
Nasty PlotDark PulseFlamethrowerCrunch
Lance
Champion
Even

Marowak trades roughly evenly with Lance's team.

Risky
Gyarados
Lv 46
WaterFlying
Intimidate
FlailDragon PulseWaterfallIce Fang
Even
Dragonite
Lv 49
DragonFlying
Inner Focus
Thunder WaveDragon RushThunderHyper Beam
Even
Dragonite
Lv 49
DragonFlying
Inner Focus
Thunder WaveDragon RushBlizzardHyper Beam
Even
Aerodactyl
Lv 48
RockFlying
Pressure
Aerial AceCrunchRock SlideThunder Fang
Even
Charizard
Lv 48
FireFlying
Blaze
Shadow ClawAir SlashDragon ClawFire Fang
Even
Dragonite
Lv 50
DragonFlying
Inner Focus
Fire BlastSafeguardOutrageHyper Beam

Catchable

Available after Badge 5
Type
Ground
Tier
E

Catch Cubone in the Safari Zone (walking, Lv 16-17, uncommon).

View Cubone locations

Evolve Cubone to Marowak

Level 28
Type
Ground
Tier
C

Cubone evolves into Marowak at Level 28. Your Cubone should hit Level 28 before you reach Jasmine, at typical leveling pace.

View Marowak locations

Recommended Moves

How to Get Cubone in HeartGold & SoulSilver

Mornings and daytime are your window for Cubone, at a couple of low-level spots. You can grab one early if you go looking, though the uncommon rates mean it is not something you trip over.

Wild Cubone may be holding when caught:

Thick Club (5% chance) An item to be held by CUBONE or MAROWAK. It is a hard bone of some sort that boosts the Attack stat.

2 locations to catch Cubone

Encountered via tall grass encounters

Badge 6
Badge 7
Badge 8
Post-Game

Where To Catch Cubone in HGSS

The line opens with Cubone at Lv. 10-17 via walking encounters. 2 catchable stages total, with locations listed for each one below.

Want the exact numbers? Work out your catch odds in HeartGold & SoulSilver for Cubone.

How to Get Shiny Cubone in HeartGold & SoulSilver

Cubone hides in Rock Tunnel and the Safari Zone, but breeding it Masuda-style is the fastest way to a shiny. Compare Shiny Cubone odds across every game

Normal vs Shiny
Normal Cubone in HeartGold & SoulSilverNormal
Shiny Cubone in HeartGold & SoulSilver Shiny
Color ShiftBrown
Shiny TierB Tier Shiny

Shiny Cubone Evolution

2 Forms
Showing shiny artworkView Full Evolution Chart

HeartGold & SoulSilver Shiny Cubone Calculator

2 Methods
Fastest Path

The best route is Masuda Method, about 1 in 1,639 on each try.

Step 1 · Encounter Method2 in HeartGold & SoulSilver

Masuda Method: Breed with a parent from a different-language game. Works on any breedable line.

Full Odds: Walk through grass, surf, or fish. Every encounter is its own independent shiny roll.

How many you have done, or plan to do.

120,000
Shiny Odds Per Try1 / 1,639Masuda Method
Chance By Now50.0%at 1,136 eggs hatchedAbout 5 in 10 hunters have one by now
What To Expect
ChanceEncountersTime
10%lucky few173----
25%one in four472----
50%coin flip1,136----
90%very likely3,773----
How is this calculated?

Every encounter has the same shiny chance, the Shiny Odds Per Try shown above. Each one is a separate roll that does not care how many you have already done, so the more you hunt, the higher your overall chance of at least one shiny. The formula below turns your odds and your number of tries into that combined chance.

chance after N tries = 1 − (1 − p)^N,  where  p = 1 / odds per try

Example at 1 in 8,192 (classic full odds): about 864 encounters for a 10 percent chance, 5,678 for 50 percent, and 18,862 for 90 percent.

The table above flips that around: it shows how many encounters it takes to reach a 10, 25, 50, and 90 percent chance at your current odds. Turning on boosts like the Shiny Charm, sandwiches, or chains improves your odds, so the encounter numbers drop.

These are estimates, not promises. Most games have no pity counter, meaning no guaranteed shiny no matter how many you hunt, so even Very Likely is not guaranteed: some hunters find one early, others go well past that point.

Where these shiny odds come from: Read our full methodology

Curious how fast a hunt could go? Work out your HeartGold & SoulSilver shiny odds for Cubone.

Cubone Weakness

Cubone is weak to Water, Grass, and Ice. On the flip side, it's immune to Electric-type moves entirely. Lightning Rod grants an additional Electric immunity, reshaping the matchup chart. Cubone's physical bulk (base 95 Def) helps cushion physical weakness hits, but special attackers are the bigger threat.

Cubone Weakness and Resistance Chart
DamageTypes
2x (Weak)Water, Grass, Ice
0.5x (Resist)Poison, Rock
0x (Immune)Electric
Gen IV Type Chart
  • Fairy type does not exist — Dragon has fewer checks
  • Physical / Special split now per-move (introduced Gen IV)

What is Cubone Weak Against

Avg
3Weak
2Resist
2Immune
Score-1
4xCritical
None
½xResist
¼xResist
None

What is Cubone Strong Against

5Strong
2Resisted
1Immune
Score+2

Best Pokemon Against Cubone

C
Jumpluff
Jumpluff
GrassFlying
C
Victreebel
Victreebel
GrassPoison
C
Vileplume
Vileplume
GrassPoison
C
B

Cubone Evolutions

Cubone is the base form in a two-stage line leading to Marowak. Check the evolution method below. Plenty of partners for breeding via one egg group. Eggs take an average time to hatch. Evolving adds up to 105 stat points total. View every chain in the Evolution Chart.

How to Evolve

2 Forms
Stat Comparison 2 Stages
Cubone
Ground
Marowak
Ground
HP
50
60+10
ATK
50
80+30
DEF
95
110+15
SP.ATK
40
50+10
SP.DEF
50
80+30
SPE
35
45+10
BST
320E-Tier
425C-Tier+105
ROLE
Balanced
Balanced
TYPE
Utility
Physical

Breeding

Very Easy

Breed Cubone easily with 63 breeding partners from the Monster egg group. Pass egg moves like Ancient Power, Belly Drum, Detect and 7 more to offspring.

Egg Groups
Monster
Gender
♂50.0%♀50.0%
Hatch Time
20 cycles·5,140 steps
Quick~5 min with Flame Body
Egg Moves
10moves
Breed With (best first)
venusaurcharizardblastoisenidokingmeganiumferaligatrampharossceptileswampertslowbrorhydonslowking

HGSS Cubone Best Moveset

Ground type with 95 Defense absorbing physical hits above its level, but 50 Attack and 35 Speed provide no offensive return. AbilityRock Head removes recoil, which barely matters at these power levels. Evolve to Marowak.

Best Build

Experimental
Physical Tank
Ability
Rock Head
Item
Thick Club
Best Nature for Cubone

Cubone best EVs are HP and Attack

EVs

Physical Tank Moveset

  • EarthquakeSTAB
  • Double Edge
  • Fire Punch
  • Swords Dance

Moves List

The TM pool is where it gets interesting. Coverage across 10 types means almost nothing walls Cubone cleanly, with Earthquake and Earth Power anchoring the STAB side. Matchup flexibility isn't a problem.

Level-Up Moves

Lv 1
Growl
D—10040Normal
Lv 3
Tail Whip
——10030Normal
Lv 7
Bone Club
—978520Ground
Lv 11
Headbutt
D7010015Normal
Lv 13
Leer
——10030Normal
Lv 17
Focus Energy
———30Normal
Lv 21
Bonemerang
B759010Ground
Lv 23
Rage
D2010020Normal
Lv 27
False Swipe
—4010040Normal
Lv 31
Thrash
—12010020Normal
Lv 33
Fling
D—10010Dark
Lv 37
Bone Rush
—379010Ground
Lv 41
Endeavor
D—1005Normal
Lv 43
Double-Edge
B12010015Normal

TM Moves

All 28 TMs are obtainable before the Elite Four

TM
TM40
Aerial AceMt. Mortarnot until badge 8
D60—20Flying
TM45——10015Normal
TM14D120705Ice
TM28
DigNational Parkbadge 2
C12010010Ground
TM26
EarthquakeVictory Roadnot until badge 8
B15010010Ground
TM54
False SwipeGoldenrod Department Storebadge 2
—4010040Normal
TM38D120855Fire
TM35
FlamethrowerGoldenrod Game Cornerbadge 2
D9510015Fire
TM01
Focus Punch-3Prize for defeating Chuckbadge 5
C15010020Fighting
TM21
FrustrationCeladon Department Storebadge 2
D—10020Normal
TM10
Hidden PowerLake of Ragebadge 6
D6010015Normal
TM13
Ice BeamGoldenrod Game Cornerbadge 2
D9510010Ice
TM23D1007515Steel
TM83
Natural GiftGoldenrod Department Storebadge 2
D—10015Normal
TM17C——10Normal
TM44
RestRoute 31badge 2
C——10Psychic
HM06D4010015Fighting
TM39
Rock TombUnion Cavebadge 1
D609510Rock
TM43
Secret PowerLake of Ragebadge 6
—7010020Normal
HM04D8010015Normal
TM90
SubstituteGoldenrod Game Cornerbadge 2
A——10Normal
TM87
SwaggerOlivine Lighthousebadge 4
——9015Normal
TM75
Swords DanceGoldenrod Game Cornerbadge 2
B——30Normal
TM46
ThiefTeam Rocket HQbadge 6
D6010025Dark

Egg Moves

Egg
Egg
Ancient Power
D601005Rock
Egg
Belly Drum
C——10Normal
Egg
Detect+4
D——5Fighting
Egg
Double Kick
—3010030Fighting
Egg
Iron Head
D8010015Steel
Egg
Perish Song
D——5Normal
Egg
Rock Slide
A759010Rock
Egg
Screech
——8540Normal
Egg
Skull Bash
—10010010Normal
Egg
Swords Dance
B——30Normal

Tutor Moves

Tut
Tutor
Earth Power
D13510010Ground
Tutor
Endeavor
D—1005Normal
Tutor
Fire Punch
B7510015Fire
Tutor
Fury Cutter
—109520Bug
Tutor
Headbutt
D7010015Normal
Tutor
Icy Wind
D559515Ice
Tutor
Iron Defense
C——15Steel
Tutor
Knock Off
D6510020Dark
Tutor
Low Kick
D—10020Fighting
Tutor
Mud-Slap
D3010010Ground
Tutor
Snore
D4010015Normal
Tutor
Thunder Punch
A7510015Electric
Tutor
Uproar
—9010010Normal

Base Stats

Base Stats
Avg
HP50
D
Attack50
D
Defense95
B
Sp. Atk40
D
Sp. Def50
D
Speed35
F
Total320
Details
Catch Rate
Easy190 / 255
Growth Rate
Medium Fast1M XP
Height0.4 m
Weight6.5 kg
Base XP64
Abilities
Rock Head
Protects against recoil damage.
Lightning Rod
Redirects single-target electric moves to this Pokémon where possible. Absorbs Electric moves, raising Special Attack one stage.
Lightning Rod grants Electric immunity
EV Yield
HPAtkDef+1SpASpDSpe
Defense training source
Pokedex Entry

If it is sad or lonely, the skull it wears shakes and emits a plaintive and mournful sound.

It always wears the skull of its dead mother, so no one has any idea what its hidden face looks like.

Cubone HeartGold & SoulSilver Guide

  • How do I catch Cubone in the HeartGold & SoulSilver Safari Zone?

    See the Locations section above for where to find Cubone in HeartGold & SoulSilver.

    Safari rules: You can only use Safari Balls. No battling. Two tactical items shift the catch/flee trade-off:

    • Throw bait to keep Cubone from fleeing (flee rate cut to 1/4) but it becomes harder to catch (catch factor halved).
    • Throw a rock to make Cubone easier to catch (catch factor doubled) but it flees twice as often.
    • Each effect lasts 2-6 random turns; throwing one cancels the other.
  • Yes. Wild Cubone in HeartGold & SoulSilver can hold Thick Club (5%). Use Thief (TM46) or Covet to swipe the held item without affecting your catch chance. Quickest way to farm rare items like Thick Club.

  • In HeartGold & SoulSilver, for a casual playthrough, Cubone works as a placeholder. Ground coverage is useful early. The real payoff is Marowak. That's where the stats start mattering.

Game Availability

Present since Red & Blue, Cubone appears in 20 games spanning 9 generations. Gen 1 originals like Cubone have the longest track record of availability in the series.

Explore

Was this page helpful?
Thanks for your feedback!
Want to tell us more?
What was most useful?
What could be improved?
Thanks for your feedback